TfL Stopping PCN Allowed: What Drivers Can Learn Today
A TfL stopped where prohibited PCN was allowed. Learn the evidence, signs and procedural points drivers should check before challenging a penalty notice.
The Parking Ticket Pal Editorial Team
18 November 20269 min read

Ran Out of Petrol Because of a Faulty Gauge? Why This Driver Beat a TfL Ticket
Every driver has glanced at the fuel gauge, seen a comfortable quarter of a tank and thought, "plenty left." But what if the gauge is lying? And if it is, and you end up stranded on a road where stopping is banned, who pays the penalty?
A recent tribunal case against Transport for London (TfL) tackled exactly that question. The driver won, but not simply because he ran dry. The reasons he won are worth understanding, because they show how the "breakdown" exemption works in practice and how much a tribunal's view of your honesty can matter.
This article is general commentary on a single tribunal decision, not legal advice. Outcomes depend on the specific facts of each case.
The Case: A Stop Caught on Camera
The contravention was "stopped where prohibited". In London, that wording is typically used for stopping restrictions on roads such as red routes, where drivers generally cannot stop even briefly except in marked bays or for specific permitted reasons.
TfL's CCTV enforcement camera captured the vehicle stopped where it should not have been, and a Penalty Charge Notice (PCN) followed. The driver appealed to the independent adjudicator, who is the person who hears these disputes at the tribunal level.
The important point is that the driver did not dispute that the car had stopped. The camera images showed it. There was no argument about signs, lines or timing. His case rested on a single claim: he was exempt because of a breakdown.
The Arguments: What Each Side Said
The driver's case
The exemption he relied on is the standard breakdown wording found in these restrictions, namely that a person is "prevented from proceeding in the vehicle by circumstances beyond the person's control."
His explanation was this:
- He had recently bought the vehicle.
- The petrol gauge was faulty. It showed a quarter full when the tank was in fact empty.
- This was the first time the fuel had dropped that low, so it was the first time he discovered the fault.
- He had not repaired the gauge because the cost was too high. He now knows that a "quarter full" reading actually means "empty", so he simply reads it differently.
- He said he had written to TfL explaining all this and enclosed a petrol receipt from a nearby BP garage.
That last point is a small detail with real weight. A receipt from a garage close to where the car stopped backs up the story that he was dealing with a fuel problem at that location.
TfL's position
TfL disputed that it had received the driver's letter. Beyond that, according to the adjudicator, TfL made no specific comment on the breakdown exemption. It did not challenge the account of the faulty gauge, question the receipt or argue that running out of fuel was something the driver could and should have avoided.
The Decision: Appeal Allowed
The adjudicator allowed the appeal, so the PCN was cancelled.
The decision was short. The adjudicator accepted that the car had stopped as alleged, then asked whether the driver had proved the exemption. He found the driver to be a truthful witness, accepted that the car ran out of petrol because of the faulty gauge, and held that this was a breakdown beyond the driver's control. Because the exemption was proved, the appeal had to succeed.
The Legal Reasoning in Plain English
1. "Yes, I stopped" does not end the case
Many drivers assume that if the camera shows their car, the appeal is over. That is not so. Parking and stopping restrictions usually come with exemptions, specific situations where the rule does not apply. If one applies, there is no penalty, even though the car was plainly there.
This is the difference between saying "it did not happen" and "it happened, but I am excused." The driver here took the second route.
2. The burden was on the driver
When the issue is whether an exemption applies, it is generally for the driver to prove it. The adjudicator said exactly that: the Appellant "has proved the exemption."
The standard is the balance of probabilities, meaning it is more likely than not that the account is true. It is not "beyond reasonable doubt", the higher test used in criminal trials. The driver does not need to be certain, only more convincing than not.
3. What "beyond the person's control" really asks
This is where the case gets interesting. The exemption does not cover every inconvenience. The question is whether the circumstances were genuinely outside the driver's control.
Running out of fuel can be a difficult argument, because many people would say a driver should keep an eye on the tank. That kind of scepticism is understandable, and it is why such claims can fail in other cases. But the adjudicator accepted that the cause here was a hidden mechanical fault, a gauge giving false readings that the driver had no reason to suspect. A driver who sensibly relies on a working instrument is in a different position from one who simply ignored a warning light.
In plain terms, the breakdown was not carelessness. It was a mechanical failure he could not reasonably have anticipated.
4. Credibility did a lot of the work
The adjudicator's finding that the driver was "truthful" was central. In many appeals, especially those without documents, the outcome turns on whether the adjudicator believes the person in front of them. The detail of the account, including the recent purchase, the first-time discovery and the reasoning about why the gauge had not been repaired, seems to have made it believable. Excuses that are vague or shift between versions tend to land less well.
5. An unchallenged account is hard to beat
TfL did not engage with the breakdown claim. When an authority offers no response to a specific exemption argument, the adjudicator is left with the driver's evidence alone. Here that evidence was an honest explanation supported by a nearby fuel receipt. That does not mean authorities always stay silent or that silence guarantees a win, but it is a reminder that an appeal is not decided on what the authority could have said.
A note on limits
This was one adjudicator's decision on one set of facts. It does not create a rule that a faulty gauge always excuses running out of fuel. It is also worth noting that the driver, now aware of the fault, has said he compensates by reading the gauge differently. How a tribunal would view a second incident is not something this decision addresses, and a driver who knows about a defect might struggle to say a later breakdown was truly beyond their control. That last point is commentary, not a finding in this case.
Lessons for Drivers
1. Know the difference between "I did not do it" and "I was exempt." If the camera has you, a contravention argument may be hopeless, but an exemption may still be open. Look at what the restriction actually allows.
2. Evidence that fits the story matters. The petrol receipt from a nearby garage corroborated the explanation. Documents such as receipts, breakdown recovery records, repair invoices or timestamps help show that a story is not made up after the fact. Keep anything linked to the incident.
3. Be specific and consistent. The driver's account had concrete detail: when he bought the car, what the gauge showed, what he learned. Tribunals often respond better to precise accounts than to general statements. Being honest also matters more than being polished.
4. Raise the exemption clearly, and early. This driver said he wrote to TfL, which TfL denied receiving. A disputed letter is a risk. If you are making representations, keeping proof of what you sent and when (for example, a copy and proof of posting or a confirmation email) can avoid a "did they get it?" argument. For a step-by-step approach, see our guide to formal representations for PCNs.
5. Do not assume an exemption is automatic. "Breakdown" is not a magic word. The circumstances must really be beyond your control, and an adjudicator will look closely at whether the problem was avoidable. If the stakes are high, such as multiple PCNs, a complex dispute or a case that has gone beyond the tribunal stage, consider speaking to a qualified adviser. Official guidance from London Tribunals and TfL is also worth reading.
For wider context on how these tickets are handled, you may find our other analyses useful, such as what drivers can learn from TfL "stopped where prohibited" appeals and another TfL appeal that was refused, which shows how differently a case can go when the evidence is weaker.
Key Takeaway
Being on camera does not mean being liable. If an exemption genuinely applies, you can still win, but you must prove it with a believable account and evidence that backs it up.
Written by
The Parking Ticket Pal Editorial Team
Source-checked parking guidance