Restricted Bus Stop PCN: How a Merton Appeal Succeeded
A London Borough of Merton bus stop PCN appeal was allowed. Learn how to challenge restricted bus stop allegations and protect your driving rights effectively.
The Parking Ticket Pal Editorial Team
19 November 202610 min read

Council Forgot One Date on a Bus Stop Ticket. It Cost Them the Case
You park briefly beside a bus stop, return to find a Penalty Charge Notice (PCN) tucked under the wiper, and assume that is that. The contravention looks clear, so surely the only question is whether you did it.
Not quite. A PCN is a legal document, and councils have to get certain details right. If they do not, the charge can fall apart without anyone deciding whether the driver actually did anything wrong. This Merton bus stop appeal shows how that works.
The case: what happened
The driver received a PCN from the London Borough of Merton for the contravention described as "Stopped on a restricted bus stop". Bus stop restrictions are there to keep the kerb clear so buses can pull in properly and passengers can board safely, and councils enforce them firmly.
The driver appealed to the independent adjudicator. The published decision does not dwell on where the car was or what the driver was doing. It turns on something else entirely: whether the PCN itself was valid.
The appeal was allowed, so the PCN was cancelled.
The arguments
The decision as recorded does not set out the driver's arguments in detail. What it does show is that the central issue was the validity of the PCN, not whether the car stopped at the bus stop.
The council's position is also thin on the page. There is no detailed defence of the notice in the reasons. Instead, the adjudicator relied heavily on an earlier decision involving the same council, Juniper v London Borough of Merton (PATAS case 2060094982). PATAS, the Parking and Traffic Appeals Service, is now known as London Tribunals.
In that earlier case, the council was invited to explain its position on the same legal point in a separate case (2060261585). That case was adjourned several times at the council's request so it could take legal advice. In the end, the council filed a "Do Not Contest" letter, which means it did not fight the appeal. The adjudicator then asked whether the council conceded the point in all other appeals raising the same issue. The council did not respond.
With no clarification, the adjudicator decided the point on its merits, and applied the same reasoning here.
The decision
The adjudicator found that the PCN was "silent as to the date of the contravention". It gave the date of the notice, but not the date on which the alleged contravention took place. On that basis the PCN was invalid and unenforceable, and the appeal was allowed "for the same reasons" as in Juniper.
In practice, the driver did not have to show they had not stopped at the bus stop. The council's paperwork failed, so the charge could not stand.
The legal reasoning, in plain English
This is where it gets interesting, because the reasoning has a few layers.
Layer one: a PCN must contain certain information
Parking penalties are created by statute. Councils do not simply decide what a ticket should say. The law lists what a PCN must contain. If a required piece of information is missing, the notice can be legally defective, however obvious the contravention.
Layer two: the Barnet case
The adjudicator relied on a High Court decision, R (Barnet) v The Parking Adjudicator (CO/3355/2006, judgment of 2 August 2006). In that case, Mr Justice Jackson held four things, as summarised in the decision:
- Section 66(3) of the Road Traffic Act 1991 requires a PCN to state the date of the notice.
- If it does not, the PCN is invalid and unenforceable.
- Prejudice to the motorist is irrelevant. The driver does not have to show the missing information caused them any harm.
- Mentioning the date of the contravention in the section explaining why the attendant thought a penalty was payable does not count as stating the date of the notice.
Point three matters most. Courts and adjudicators sometimes forgive minor errors if the driver was not misled. Under this approach, that forgiveness is not available. The requirement is strict.
Layer three: the twist in Merton's case
Here, the PCN did state the date of the notice. What it left out was the date of the contravention. The adjudicator noted that these two dates could be different. A warden might observe a vehicle on one day and the notice might be dated another, for example if it is issued or posted later.
So the case extends the strict approach from Barnet. The adjudicator in Juniper treated a PCN as defective if the contravention date is missing, because without it the driver cannot tell from the notice which alleged event the council is relying on.
A note of caution
Readers should be careful not to over-read this. The reasoning comes from the framework in force at the time, namely section 66 of the Road Traffic Act 1991. Parking enforcement law has since been restructured, including by the Traffic Management Act 2004 and its regulations, and PCN content requirements have been restated. A decision applying older wording does not automatically decide how a modern PCN would be treated.
Adjudicators also decide each appeal on its own facts, and one decision does not bind another in the way a court judgment would. The Barnet point is a High Court ruling, but how it applies to a particular modern notice is a question for the adjudicator hearing that appeal. This article is commentary on one decision, not advice on any specific ticket.
Why the council's silence mattered
The adjudicator did not decide this in a vacuum. The council had been given the chance to put its legal case, sought repeated adjournments to take legal advice, and then declined to contest the point in the lead case. When asked whether it would take the same stance elsewhere, it did not answer.
The decision does not suggest wrongdoing by the council. It does show how tribunals respond when an authority does not engage with a clear legal challenge: the adjudicator simply decides the issue and moves on. Councils that want to defend a notice need to say so and explain why.
Lessons for drivers
1. Read the whole PCN, not just the contravention
Most people look at the amount, the location and the contravention description. This case is a reminder to read the whole document. Does it contain the key dates and details you would expect? If something looks missing or inconsistent, note it down. Whether the omission is legally significant depends on the rules that apply to that notice, but it is worth spotting.
2. Technical validity and the facts are separate questions
Drivers often think an appeal must prove innocence. Tribunals consider two different things: whether the contravention happened, and whether the PCN and the council's procedure were legally sound. A driver can lose on the first and still win on the second, or the other way round. Looking at both can matter.
3. "No harm done" is not always a defence for the council
A council might say the driver knew perfectly well what the ticket was about. Under the strict approach described in Barnet, that is not the test where a required item is missing. The question is whether the statutory requirement was met, not whether the driver was confused. That said, this was a position taken under particular legislation, so it should not be assumed to apply everywhere.
4. Raise the point properly and on time
If you think a PCN is defective, say so clearly when you challenge it. Use the council's formal process and the deadlines on the notice, and keep copies of the PCN, photos and all correspondence. Our guide to formal representations for PCNs explains how that stage works. If the council rejects your challenge, you can usually appeal to the independent tribunal, and our walkthrough of the Traffic Penalty Tribunal process gives an overview. In London, the relevant body is London Tribunals.
5. Do not rely on a technicality alone where the stakes are real
Because the law has changed since this reasoning was applied, a defect argument that worked then may not work now. If the penalty is significant, or you are facing enforcement action, consider getting advice from a qualified professional or a recognised advice service. The tribunal's own published guidance is also a good starting point. For general background, see our explainer on PCN codes, and for another example of a bus stop appeal with a different outcome, see our write-up of a Kingston bus stop PCN appeal that was allowed.
What this case does not tell us
It is easy to read too much into a short decision, so a few limits are worth stating:
- It does not say bus stop restrictions are unenforceable. They are enforceable where the notice and procedure are valid.
- It does not say every PCN missing a date will be cancelled today.
- It does not say Merton conceded the point generally. The adjudicator specifically noted that the council had not clarified its position.
The most it shows is that, on these facts and under this reasoning, a notice lacking a required piece of information could not be enforced.
Key takeaway
A PCN has to be right as well as fair. If the council gets the paperwork wrong, the charge can fail even where the driver did stop at the bus stop.
Read the notice carefully, check what it says against what it should say, and challenge in the proper way and on time. And remember that the rules evolve, so a case from one era is a guide to how tribunals think, not a guarantee of how yours will go.
This article is general information and commentary on a published tribunal decision. It is not legal advice and does not consider the circumstances of any individual PCN.
Written by
The Parking Ticket Pal Editorial Team
Source-checked parking guidance