Hounslow Suspended Bay PCN Appeal: Lessons for Drivers
A Hounslow driver won a suspended bay PCN appeal. Learn how to check suspension signs, evidence and council procedure before challenging a penalty.

The Parking Ticket Pal Editorial Team
16 November 20269 min read

The Sign That Nobody Could Prove Was There: Hounslow Suspended Bay Appeal Allowed
Most of us have parked in a bay, checked the signs, and walked away confident we got it right. But what if the sign that got you fined wasn't there when you parked? And who has to prove it either way?
A Hounslow tribunal case from July 2015 turned on exactly that question. It is a useful reminder that a council cannot simply assert that its signs were in place. It has to be able to back that up.
The case: what happened
The contravention was "parked in a suspended bay/part of bay", better known to many drivers as PCN code 21. A bay suspension is a temporary measure. A council takes a normal parking space out of use, often for roadworks, building work, a removal, filming or utility repairs. Drivers who park there during the suspension can be issued with a Penalty Charge Notice (PCN).
Mr Grainger parked his car on Devonshire Road in the London Borough of Hounslow at about 09:30 on 11 July 2015. He later received a PCN for parking in a suspended bay. He challenged it, lost at the council stage, and took the appeal to an independent adjudicator. He attended the hearing in person.
His case was simple. When he parked, he said, there was no suspension sign. He believed it had been put up after he left his car.
The arguments
The driver's case
Mr Grainger's position was that a bay suspension is only enforceable if drivers are given proper notice. If there was no sign, he could not have known the bay was out of use.
What made his appeal stronger than a bare assertion was that he backed it with evidence. He had made a Freedom of Information request to the council. The response showed that six PCNs were issued to vehicles in suspended bays in Devonshire Road on 11 July, between 11:19 and 12:03.
That timing matters. Mr Grainger parked at about 09:30, yet all six PCNs were issued from around 11:19 onwards. A reasonable inference, and the one he invited, was that the signs went up some time that morning and enforcement followed afterwards. The adjudicator did not formally rule that this is what happened, as we will see, but the data fitted his account.
The council's case
Hounslow said the suspension sign had been put up on 6 June, more than a month before the day in question. If true, that would mean drivers had had ample notice.
The only evidence offered for this was an email. It was sent by a revenue service supervisor at SERCO, the contractor, to Mr Engall, an officer at the council. In other words, the council relied on one internal message, passed on second-hand, stating when the sign was erected.
The decision
The adjudicator allowed the appeal. The PCN was cancelled.
The reasoning was short and pointed. The adjudicator noted that no evidence had been seen from the contractor who actually erected the signs, and no photographs of the sign in place on 6 June. The email alone was not enough to satisfy the adjudicator that a suspension sign was in place when Mr Grainger parked at about 09:30 on 11 July 2015. The adjudicator was therefore not satisfied that adequate notice of the suspension had been given.
The legal reasoning in plain English
1. This was an argument about proof, not about who was right
It is tempting to read this as "the adjudicator believed the driver's story about the sign going up late". That is not quite what was decided. The adjudicator did not make a finding that the sign was erected after Mr Grainger parked. The finding was narrower: the council had not shown that the sign was there.
That difference is the heart of the case. It was not enough for the driver's account to be plausible. The question was whether the council's evidence was strong enough to establish its own case.
2. The council carries the burden
In civil parking appeals, the enforcement authority has to show that the contravention occurred. The standard is the "balance of probabilities", which means more likely than not. It is far lower than the "beyond reasonable doubt" test used in criminal cases, but it still requires evidence.
A suspended bay contravention rests on the bay actually being suspended and the suspension being properly signed. If the signing is in doubt, the contravention is in doubt. Here, the council could not get over that bar.
3. Signs are the driver's only warning
Parking restrictions work because drivers can see them. A permanent restriction is shown by signs and road markings that sit there day after day. A suspension is different. It changes the rules of a bay that, the day before, may have been perfectly usable. The sign is often the only thing telling a driver that the normal rules no longer apply.
That is why adequate signing is so central to bay suspension cases. If a driver cannot reasonably be expected to know about the suspension, it is difficult to say they have breached it. Tribunals take the quality and timing of the signing seriously for this reason.
4. Why the email fell short
The email in this case was, in effect, a statement from one person to another that the work had been done on a particular date. It was not a record made at the time, and it was not from the person who did the work. Nor was it backed by a photograph.
Adjudicators weigh evidence rather than simply counting it. A dated photograph of a sign, a signed statement from the operative who installed it, a completed work sheet or a time-stamped log would each carry more weight than a supervisor's summary email. Without any of these, the adjudicator was left with an assertion.
It is also worth noticing how the council's date interacts with the FOI data. A sign supposedly in place from 6 June sits oddly alongside six PCNs all issued after 11:19 on the day in question. This doesn't prove the sign was late, but it was precisely the sort of question the council's evidence needed to answer, and did not.
5. The value of the FOI request
One of the most interesting features of the case is how the driver built his evidence. The Freedom of Information Act 2000 lets members of the public ask public bodies for recorded information. Mr Grainger used it to obtain data that the council itself held about enforcement on the day. That gave him something objective to point to, rather than relying on memory alone.
Lessons for drivers
This is case commentary, not advice for any individual's situation, but several practical themes emerge.
1. Check the signs, and record them. If you park next to a bay and there is no sign, or you are unsure, a dated photograph of the whole street scene is valuable. Take wide shots as well as close-ups, and make sure the images show the time. If the sign is not there when you park, you are unlikely ever to be able to prove that later without a record.
2. Timing evidence can be powerful. The strongest part of Mr Grainger's case was the pattern of PCN issue times. If your own situation involves a suspension that you believe was not in place when you parked, look at when the enforcement happened. Other PCNs issued nearby, and when, may shed light on when enforcement really began. Be aware this kind of argument works best alongside other evidence, not on its own.
3. Councils must prove their case with real evidence. A council is entitled to say its signs were in place, but if challenged it has to support that. If you believe the signing was inadequate, it is reasonable to ask what evidence the council holds, such as installation records or photographs. Our guide to using unclear parking signs as a defence explains how signage arguments work more generally, and our explainer on PCN code 21 covers this contravention in detail.
4. The Freedom of Information Act is a tool, not a guarantee. Requests can produce useful data, but responses vary and take time. A request will not rescue a weak case, and you should be careful about deadlines in the PCN process while waiting. If you are unsure how the stages fit together, our step-by-step guide to the tribunal process is a good place to start, and our piece on formal representations shows how to put your case to the council in writing.
5. Each case turns on its own facts. This decision does not mean every suspended bay PCN will be cancelled when a sign is questioned. Other adjudicators, faced with strong installation records or clear photographs, may well reach the opposite conclusion. And an adjudicator's decision on one set of facts does not bind others. Where the penalty is significant or the circumstances are complicated, consider seeking professional advice or looking at official guidance from the tribunal service.
Key takeaway
A council cannot just say its sign was there. It has to prove it.
In this case, a single internal email, with no contractor evidence and no photographs, was not enough to show a suspension was properly signed at 09:30 on 11 July 2015. If you are ever challenging a suspended bay PCN, the question to ask is not only "what do I remember?" but "what evidence exists, and who has to produce it?"
This article is general information and commentary on a published tribunal decision. It is not legal advice, and the outcome of any other appeal will depend on its own evidence and circumstances.

Written by
The Parking Ticket Pal Editorial Team
Source-checked parking guidance